Mellow and Thought-Provoking: In the Valley of Elah

In the Valley of Elah
Directed by Paul Haggis
Released September 14, 2007

How could director Paul Haggis follow up the massive but controversial success that was the Oscar-winning “Crash”? This is the answer. Here is another disturbing and affecting film which will upset some with its semi-ambiguous notions about war and the military. Tommy Lee Jones, in a truly excellent and reserved performance, portrays the stubborn father of an MIA soldier, someone who will stop at nothing to get to the truth. The premise, as it stands, might not seem starkly interesting or original, but Haggis’ take on the story helps it rise above normal expectations for this kind of film. The best surprise here is Charlize Theron, who gives her Typical Sympathetic But Seemingly Powerless Cop character her all. The film’s message is a bit unclear up until the very last frame, but the film as a whole is still an intriguing and worthwhile experience.

B+